Quick heal is facing tough times ever
since it has made its debut in the stock market. There are doubts over its
capability to withstand the competition from MNC brands. But I am still
positive on the company and its inherent strength to offer high tech security
solutions catering to the demands and needs of Indian market.
I know so many people who think that Woodland
shoe is an MNC brand and it certainly impacts their buying decision. So many
people take Van Heusen as a foreign brand when in fact it belongs to our Aditya
Birla group. People doubt Quick heal as they know that it is an indian player
otherwise what it has achieved as a brand among the giant IT commodity players
like TCS/Infosys is certainly a great
achievement. We have never heard about an Indian Brand in technology...we see
Microsoft, Java, Oracle, Adobe, Norton, Kaspersky everywhere and we hardly know
what our IT giants (Infosys/TCS/Wipro) do. Indianness is invisible in IT for us
in branded products although the fact is that most of the Global IT giants are
headed by Indians.
So there shouldn't be any doubt on
the capability...it is only about the intent to choose the difficult path of
brand and product building which is chosen by Quick Heal backed by strong
technical capabilities. Quick heal has already covered some genuine distance,
it is not some fairy-tale startup. Quick heal is a serious profit making
organization, NP of around 50-60 cr on revenues of around 300 cr with strong in
house R&D capabilities.
Our world is changing fast and in a
sense we are moving towards non-material sort of world. Physical wars among big
nations are not happening and chances are even lesser. Modern wars comprise
currency wars and Cyber wars. We are moving more and more towards
automation...most of the civil services will be fully automated in few
years...cloud and IOT will bring radical changes to how Govt provides services.
So any security breach will be serious...catastrophic. General public is doing
everything online...our bank accounts/passwords are online. My enemy doesn't
need to rob me personally/physically...he can do the same thousands KM away
without even touching anything. So risks here are very serious and can't be
left uncovered. We'll see huge demand for security products when people will
realize the vulnerability of our online life. So i have no doubt about the
future scale of operation.
Here i remember the hacking attack on
dating site Ashley Madison which threatened to kill the life of its members and
the business. Hackers threatened to public the names of its members claimed to
be some 38 million. People panicked and small number of suicides were
reported, a priest in Louisiana among them. So i feel threat is very potent and
deadly for people to ignore it or taking it lightly. In fact people will only
become more aware in the future. Current stage is just the tip of possible
iceberg.
Stock markets are never perfect and
it is good that they are like that as otherwise there will e nothing for us to
find hidden deep value proposition. Like here, on one hand our market is
finding it difficult to assign high valuation to Quick heal but still it is
finding great value on other security company which is more like a Labour
supplier involving relatively much lower technical expertise. I am talking
about Security and Intelligence services India Ltd (SIS Ltd) which is trading
at a PE of around 60 but Quick heal which is having much higher technical expertise
with much stronger brand recall is trading at a PE of around 20 ( If we keep
out the impact of GST on June-17 results). QH is also having around 375 cr in investments and cash!!
Its June-17 Qtr results were impacted
by de-stocking by dealers ahead of GST implementation but still its enterprise
business grew by almost 20% even in this tough environment which shows that
Quick heal is on the right path as far as picking Enterprise business. For past
2-3 quarters, its performance is impacted by industry level macro issues like
Demonetization and GST but i think the growth will be back very soon.
India has big number of SME’s who earlier
never bothered about the cyber security. But off late, SME sector was also
getting aware of Security threats and spending was growing. SME got involved as
earlier the threat was only to information (For SME) and their information was
never valuable for hackers but as more and more SME was turning towards online
banking etc....their threats were rising...so there will be high growth in SME
and large enterprises sector in India.
Paid Security products vs
Free products
Some people opine that general public
will be reluctant to pay for the security software products as many are
available free. Although i can't claim to understand cyber security better than
an IT professional but there are certain things which i feel will pave the
growth of paid cyber security products. First thing i always feel there are no
free lunches. The free games we play, free videos we play...all have either
embedded with the device maker/operating system maker or they need intermediate
ads or else the free product is mediocre.
When you think that you have found a free antivirus product then the real fact is that “You” have become a product for these companies. They will bomber your system with all type of nonsensical stuff like free toolbar, search engine etc. and in doing so they make money of you…so here you are the product. Free antivirus companies are just like other companies…they need profits to sustain themselves. So free antivirus products bundle all type of junk like adware, spyware, toolbars, tracking and other cheap stuff to make money from you. They will alter your search engine to make you click ads, some install terrible Ask toolbar which is nothing short of a nightmare, harvesting and selling your browsing data and other information. Even the reputed free antivirus companies like Avanst, Avira, AVG, Comodo are doing this. These free products market their other premium programs, upgraded paid versions of their free antivirus program to make people to pay for this and in the process they make big money.
When you think that you have found a free antivirus product then the real fact is that “You” have become a product for these companies. They will bomber your system with all type of nonsensical stuff like free toolbar, search engine etc. and in doing so they make money of you…so here you are the product. Free antivirus companies are just like other companies…they need profits to sustain themselves. So free antivirus products bundle all type of junk like adware, spyware, toolbars, tracking and other cheap stuff to make money from you. They will alter your search engine to make you click ads, some install terrible Ask toolbar which is nothing short of a nightmare, harvesting and selling your browsing data and other information. Even the reputed free antivirus companies like Avanst, Avira, AVG, Comodo are doing this. These free products market their other premium programs, upgraded paid versions of their free antivirus program to make people to pay for this and in the process they make big money.
Cyber security is a very complex
segment which requires huge resources (most of which are used immediately i.e
salary) which needs commercial success of the product. Updating of data base
for viruses is very costly and it is a continuous exercise.
Besides free software lacks so many
things which are must for a complete security software like:
1) Don’t provide for online backup in
case of any emergency
2) Encryption of files in case of
theft.
3) Internet security
4) Spam filtering
5) Quick updation of virus
definitions and library
6) Ads area big distraction and
consume resources
7) Most importantly, support system
like onsite installation and telephonic support is never there which for a
small business is a make or break decision. Quick support in case of a crisis
will play the deciding factor in saving the business; even for a common layman.
There are so many cases where cyber-crime resulted in the failure of a thriving
business like recent attack on Sony which almost killed the giant.
Cyber wars: Indigenous “Make
in India” products are key for India
Cyber warfare is the
future of wars between nations. For long, China has attacked India’s cyber
space and networks. The numbers of such attacks are rising continuously around
50000 a year. In 2010, Ministry of Defence computers were hacked pointing
serious weakness of our systems. This year in May-June, hackers attacked the
systems of Indian Banks and stole the data of around 3 million debit cards and
the worst part was that Indian authorities couldn’t even establish the origin
of the attack, the identity of the hackers, or how the securely
self-destructing malware was created.
Israel is the global giant
in cyber security space and US companies are the biggest investors in the Israeli
cyber security start-ups. In Israel citizens are supposed to give their
services in Army in young age. Israeli Citizens are one of the most patriotic nations
of the world and their citizens are ready to serve and die for the country at
any time. Time spent by young ones in the army makes them capable to understand
the nitty-gritty of security systems and this is the reason for their success
in Cyber security. USA and Israel are close ally in cyber war fare but both
have maintained silence on their actual capabilities to originate a serious
cyber attack and their expertise in defending such attacks.
Such ambiguity about the
strength of cyber system puts your attackers in doubt as they can only guess
your cyber technical expertise which puts them in back foot. Both USA and
Israel created one of the most sophisticated Stuxnet Worm to attack on Iran’s
nuclear systems in 2010 although they both never acknowledged the same. Stuxnet
is regarded as one of the most sophisticated malware ever discovered. So I do
not know whether India should adopt such policy to keep silence about their
expertise but if we go by the recent attacks on our Defence systems it is clear
that we are still have some distance to cover. Israel is also a close ally of
India and I see both India and Israel strengthening their cyber systems with
mutual assistance. India really have great IT skilled professionals who if
given the chance can prove their true worth in developing the cyber security
systems for India.
Here, I want to stress
that Indian Govt is going to prefer Indian made cyber security products as it
ensures that the source code that runs the programme and the machinery do not
grant access to foreign firms or governments. So I think local firms like Quick
heal can tap this huge opportunity along with the fact that they have already demonstrated
their expertise and acumen in designing and developing security systems.
Regarding Quick Heal vs MNC players,
i think Quick heal has everything to challenge them because this is what it has
been doing so for a fairly lengthy period of time. It is having more than 30%
share of retail market. MNC IT players are overhyped...they are good but
Indians are not less. The only thing is the risk taking capability as focus on
being a branded product player is a big risk which requires huge resources for
branding and distribution. In fact the main aim for Quick heal going for IPO was to get money for
brand promotion and we can see that Quick Heal is now visible across Media
which i feel is a great attempt.
Actually R&D and Branding is a
different business games which i feel Indian investors don't understand at all.
We always fail to value a R&D heavy company; we try to figure out the
earnings when R&D is a long term game although with unimaginable growth
prospectus. Same is for a Branded product company. Here Quick heal is trying
both which is new first for Indian business. Giants like Infosys, TCS have
never had the courage for going for product based future...timid...although
they have the huge resources. But they failed terribly in understanding the
future of IT...which was migrating from quick service product to value added
products like Artificial intelligence.
As i have explained in many blog
posts R&D and Branding is not for chicken hearted; it is for brave
warriors...it is journey to the unknown. Quick Heal has chosen this difficult
path although it is very strong in R&D and developed some ground breaking
solution in security.
Also i think Mobile security will see
huge growth from here on. Recent attack on Android phones will make people
realize the threat.
I have great faith in Quick Heal...and
i feel there are high chances of it to survive its quest for the unknown. Good
buy at current levels of 190.
(Views
are personal and should not be taken as a recommendation for buying or
selling a stock. Stock markets are inherently risky so kindly do your
Due Diligence before investing. I am not a certified Sebi Analyst and
holding the shares discussed in this Post)
Sir your View on LEEL Electricals pls. its PEER DIXON IS getting listed at 40PE. LEEL available at 12PE. SHARE YOUR VIEW PLS.
ReplyDeleteHi Dear, I have never studied LEEL so not in a position to comment on its future. I am not sure what led to the management to sell their B2C business as earlier they were very bullish on that because i think Indian AC/TV kit manufacturers require considerable tweaking in their business model as at present Indian AC/TV kit producers are more like assemblers.
DeleteMost of them import the main components of the Kits from places like china and so they don’t do much value addition after that. Like for LEEL, raw material expenditure in foreign currency was 1000 cr out of total raw material cost of 1700 cr against turnover of 2400 cr. PBIT was 235 cr which is just 10% of turnover which is mainly due to the fact that they do not add much value. If you see the cooling kits of your AC’s you will not find the brand name of the Indian companies because they are not manufacturing them. That does why I feel in order to become a truly B2B company, Indian manufacturers have to take more things in their hands.
LEEL is in the same position where Piramal Enterprises was in 2011 after selling their generic pharma business to Abbot for 17000 cr and after that Piramal has created huge value for shareholders. But I think LEEL management is good and they are trying to up the value chain by paying all the debt. I don’t have much info about their future plans so my views are constrained due to this.